Chasing the WInd

Global Petroleum Club ImageCould the proposed Nantucket Sound wind farm become obsolete before it is even built?

Aesthetic concerns have stalled the Cape Wind project, which would erect 130 turbines 5 to 13 miles from Cape Cod and Nantucket. But technological advances in recent years are allowing developers elsewhere to consider building wind turbines farther from shore, where they would be less visible.

Last month, the US Department of the Interior granted the nation’s first ocean leases for exploring the feasibility of large wind farms, with most of the sites 12 to 18 miles off New Jersey and Delaware. New York power companies are exploring the possibility of a vast wind farm 13 miles off the Rockaways. And a 120-turbine farm has been proposed 48 miles off New Bedford.

If these and similar projects prove viable, some wind energy specialists and developers say, they could leapfrog closer-to-shore projects like Cape Wind. Winds are often stronger and more sustained farther from shore.

Yet these proposed wind farms face enormous hurdles. Most will require new, unproven structural designs to withstand fiercer seas and deeper water. They are farther from the onshore electrical grid and more expensive to build. Only one deep-water project exists in the world - a two-turbine test farm 12 miles off the east coast of Scotland in about 150 feet of water.

“People do take Cape Wind into account and try to avoid the same kind of controversy,’’ said Walt Musial, principal engineer of the National Renewable Energy Laboratory in Colorado, part of the US Department of Energy. “But the trade-off is that the deeper the project is, the greater the technical risk in terms of reliability, survivability, and . . . payback.’’

The Cape Wind project is proposed in what wind energy specialists say is probably the best place on the East Coast to build the nation’s first wind farm: in protected shallow waters close to shore. That allows developers to use technology already proven for land-based wind turbines, driving an enormous single steel pole into the seabed and placing a turbine on top.

But in water 100 to 200 feet deep, that same structure loses stability and can cost too much. So a race is now on to construct wind turbines using much the same technology as used for oil rigs. This method would involve driving pilings into the seabed and mounting a structure on top. The turbines are built on land, carried by barges, and then placed on the structure.

In even deeper water, such as on the West Coast, or in the Gulf of Maine, scientists envision floating turbines anchored to the seabed, although most acknowledge the technology is still years away from being economically viable. Blue H, the company proposing a project off New Bedford, hopes to test its design for floating turbines in US waters by 2011.

“Projects in shallow waters visible from shore have been proposed in the US and many have had public support but others have had some resistance,’’ said Habib Dagher, director of the Advanced Structures and Composites Center at the University of Maine, which wants to host a deep-water wind research center at the university and test designs in deep state waters 3 miles from shore. “In Maine, our goal for large-scale commercial development is to go about 20 miles offshore so you don’t see the structures from land, and to capture the best winds. But it’s a big learning curve for that depth.’’

Wind turbines need to be about 20 miles offshore to be invisible from land, many wind researchers say, although those that are at least 13 miles offshore are barely visible most of the time.

There is no rule about how far away an offshore wind park must be to win public support, said Willett Kempton, professor of marine policy at the University of Delaware. Yet surveys he conducted of thousands of coastal residents show there is little opposition to projects at least 8 miles offshore. Yet with no turbines built offshore in the United States, he added, it is hard to gauge public reaction.

Given the opposition to Cape Wind, developers are acutely sensitive to public perceptions. Deepwater Wind, which is hoping to build a two-phase project in partnership with Rhode Island, moved most of the proposed turbines farther offshore than the state had requested to improve aesthetics, wind power, and safety for birds. The company wants to construct up to eight turbines near Block Island, using a structure anchored to the seabed. Then it plans to build an additional 110 turbines about 15 to 18 miles out in federal waters to generate power for sale to the electrical grid. The company also received two of the federal exploratory leases 12 to 18 miles off New Jersey.

“Our philosophy is as far from the coastline as possible,’’ said Jim Lanard, managing director of Deepwater. “We think wind parks are a beautiful sight, but we understand some people don’t like them. The turbines can look - even though they are not - chaotically placed near shore because they are spinning at different times and speeds.’’

Bluewater Wind LLC, which also won two exploratory federal leases, is using technology similar to Cape Wind’s for two large projects 14 to 18 miles off New Jersey and Delaware. Founder and president Peter Mandelstam said the relatively shallow water, strong winds, and proven technology will make it faster and easier to build and maintain a wind farm.

Musial, of the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, said it makes more sense to build nearer-to-shore projects first, to work out technical problems, before jumping ahead to more challenging conditions farther out at sea.

Closer-to-shore wind turbines are certainly not being abandoned.

The Cape Wind project is waiting for a final federal sign-off. And Massachusetts recently unveiled a draft ocean zoning plan that designates six areas within 3 miles of shore where up to 10 wind turbines could be built in each, but only if most communities want them. The state also set aside two areas for large-scale wind farms offshore from two nearly empty islands.

Ian Bowles, Massachusetts secretary of Energy and Environmental Affairs, said a suite of wind farms - onshore and those at varying distances offshore - are needed to meet ambitious national and state renewable energy goals.

“We are going to need all this and a lot more,’’ he said.

0
Your rating: None
categories:

JOIN OUR FORUM

Global Petroleum Forum (GPF) is one of the most active energy website communities on the internet today. Members can provide related content on the forum page or commentary on the website blog.

commented blog posts

mudiaga's account

D2 (Gas Oil)FOR SALE

Algae are tiny biological factories that use photosynthesis to transform carbon dioxide and sunlight into energy so efficiently that they can double their weight several times a day. As part of the...

gpc_admin's account

Texas Institute of Science

Texas Institute of Science is the leading global entity providing research, development, testing, and application engineering services to its Client’s R&D divisions around the world. Through...

gpc_joanna's account

Russia May Lose Its Monopoly on Gas Supplies to...

Late July officials from six countries met in Turkey and signed an agreement to build the Nabucco pipeline. The pipeline will run from Turkey’s eastern border through Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary...

Pasvar's account

New way to generate additional income

The rapidly growing 'Network of Professionals' program of Texas Institute of Science (www.TxIS.us) is aimed at highly motivated professionals who interact with technology-based companies in their...

uchenna's account

BEIJNG FIRM TO INVEST IN NIGERIA’S OWN ORIENT...

  One of the most enterprising people you will ever get to meet in the whole of Africa, are the Nigerian people from the southeastern region, they say. I have not really been around Africa but...

reginag's account

Picking the Right Golf Clubs

If you are considering taking up the great sport of golf for exercise, business concerns, or merely as a hobby, you should make sure you are picking the right golf clubs for your particular golf game...

Pasvar's account

An “intermediary” role between Corporations...

With the world facing one of the most significant economic downturns in the last century, an increasing number of corporations are acting very cautious with their existing liquid assets....

commented forum posts

dan the oil man's account

Lets Be Silly tm

Here at Lets Be Silly tm and our correspondents, Because Oil Matters tm, we are dedicated to being silly and making oil matter Zeig Heil to the Oil!

gpc_phil's account

Climate Change

Climate change is a hot topic in politics and on the web.  Some refer to it as "Global Warming" but here we can accept all view points. Our world is changing including the weather...

ebipere's account

Oil service companies

Looking for technical partners to set up JV oil service company in West Africa/Nigeria. Primarily to bring in expertise Not Capital. thx Ebipere

mossboss's account

Biodiesel

Hello All Here How interesting! The petroleum club has in fact, a spot for biofuels It seems at this stage, I am the only one here who is involved in biofuels If that is not so, could the others if...

angelusjames's account

Will the naval buildup in the Persian Gulf have...

With coalition naval forces moving into position in the Persian Gulf to protect Bahrain and Saudi oil facilities from al-Quaeda threats, do you think Iran may view this as military pressure on them...

Robinson's account

CAT3512 units new for sale

Anyone looking for CAT3512 brand new 2003 models with desert radiators? I have multiple units available. Middle East location for inspection.

angelusjames's account

opportunities in Saudi Arabia

A large Saudi engineering and construction company is looking for English-speaking managers to oversee their infrastructure projects and pubic works; civil and electrical and mechanical engineers,...

new users

cippe's account
paire996's account
chief surveyor's account
preziaL's account
simonharding's account
Tankchat.com's account
JOshG's account
jlongsworth's account
sabieneL's account
rudolf163's account
Lukasz Olejniczak's account
Zivioganj's account
Chad Wilson's account
Shaira A's account
Vlad_Kholodov's account
recelaV's account
VioletR's account
Susan Song's account
freshersjobs13's account
SamilB's account
vedkari nath tripathi's account
Frank LABROUSSE's account
Sutulina's account
Ruslan Nurmanov's account
LeonardoU's account
Anton Prodanovic's account
midwesto's account

most active users

Orlando09's account

Telescopes to show universe soon after Big

Consequat ante ac ut sit vel molestie hendrerit et mollis Vestibulum. Laoreet leo ac pretium augue dolor nunc Sed tempor libero at. Gravida id malesuada Nulla enim enim nibh Nam vitae platea lacinia...Consequat ante ac ut sit vel molestie hendrerit et mollis Vestibulum. Laoreet leo ac

NEWSLETTER

Please Register or Login to subscribe our Newsletter.